Agreement with another model is not evidence of correctness. A primitive gains authority only through measured calibration on held-out data.
Architecture contract
Initial gate per primitive:- A calibration artifact bound to the exact model, revision, runtime, question and candidate schema.
- Expected calibration error at or below 0.05 on held-out data.
- At most 5% observed error on the auto-act subset.
- A statistically meaningful held-out sample reported with confidence bounds.
- Reversible, low-consequence decisions only at first.
- Hard policy and deterministic verification stay authoritative.
- Abstain or escalate outside the calibrated coverage region.
Current implementation
The decision runtime is on main and S1 runs shadow-only: it records what it would have decided and takes no action. One primitive,judge.first_pass.tool, has passed the Q26 gate and runs in a budgeted canary when live mode is on; its audits feed the CUSUM rollback. See Calibration.